Devolution to the North of England

King Oswald's Banner, used to represent the greater region and former kingdom of Northumbria.
Northern England as defined along Historic Counties

Northern England devolution is the broad term used to describe the wish for devolved governmental powers that would give more autonomy to the Northern Counties (those northern parts of England in the North–South divide in the United Kingdom).

Whilst definitions of the North vary, it is commonly defined as the border with Scotland in the north, to the Midlands, or near the River Trent, in the south. This is currently defined by three governmental statistical regions: North West England, Yorkshire and the Humber, and North East England.

History[edit]

Main article: Northern England § History

Prior to the unification of England in the 10th century, Northern England had broadly constituted the Kingdom of Northumbria, deriving from the Old English Norþan-hymbre meaning "the people or province north of the Humber".[1]

One of the first bodies formed in modern times to address local autonomy issues and grievances was the "Council of the North" formed in 1988. This was in response to the North's concern with the taking over of York-based Rowntree by the Swiss firm, Nestlé. The original Council of the North had last met in the 17th century to deal with the chaos of the English Civil War. The council met, and while it was attended by noted businessmen and politicians, little came of it and the movement soon petered out.[2]

The more recent push for Scottish independence has had its effect on the North of England, with the 2004 North East England devolution referendum held in order to decide whether to establish a parliament for the North.[3] This has partly been spurred on by the feeling that London and the south are culturally different to the North,[2] with some commentary stating that the "real" English are seen as the South.[4][2] There are also concerns that if Scotland was to become independent, then economic factors associated with this would negatively affect the North, with industry/investment going to Scotland with possible tax breaks. Establishing a separate country or autonomous region is seen by some as a way to stop this.[3] Alternatively, a potential more successful focussed economic hub based around Scotland could benefit the North of England, as their population centre is closer to it than to London.[5] To some, the differences between London and Scotland are similar to the differences between London and the North of England.[5]

Economically, North Eastern Businesses have called for greater control over the region's financial affairs.[6] However, despite these sentiments, the 2004 referendum for more autonomy was convincingly rejected, with a voter turnout of 45%.[7][8] 2015 saw a petition for part of the North to secede and join Scotland gain 28,000 signatures.[9]

Contemporary movement[edit]

The Northern England government regions (North East England, North West England and Yorkshire and the Humber) in England.

In 2014, the people within the North of England indicated in a survey by the BBC that there was a greater wish for devolution of some powers at least. The survey indicated that 85% of people in the North wanted control of policing, taxation and education handed over to the region.[10] There is also a perceived continuing widening of the North-South divide, which continues to highlight the issue to people living in the North.[11][12] Government policy relating to the COVID-19 pandemic also created tension between the North and the UK Government, which gave rise to some discussion of a separate region as a way of giving more say to the area.[13][11]

Various parties have been formed to test the issues in elections, including the North East Party in 2014[14] and the Northern Party in 2015.[15][16] The Yorkshire Party looks specifically at the issue of a devolved assembly for Yorkshire.[11][12]

A smaller movement exists in Liverpool.[17][18][19][20] The sonoric landscape of spoken Scouse extends beyond contemporary political and geographic boundaries of the City of Liverpool and instead extends to Merseyside as a whole.[21][22] An estimated three-quarters of Liverpudlians have Irish ancestry[citation needed], causing some to identify more strongly as Scouse or Irish than English. In 1885, the historic constituency Liverpool Scotland elected an Irish Nationalist, T. P. O'Connor, as their MP, and 59% voted remain in the 2016 EU referendum.[23] #ScouseNotEnglish trended on Twitter following the result of the 2019 general election as Merseyside constituencies had some of the highest Labour vote shares in the country.[24][25] The phrase "Scouse not English" resonates strongly in Liverpool, reflecting a unique identity and heritage that has fuelled a growing debate on the possibility of the city achieving independence from the rest of England. This divisive discourse, influenced by historical sentiments and contemporary political differences, has gained traction on social media, prompting discussions on whether Liverpool should pursue autonomy through a referendum.[26]

"Liverpool has historically perceived itself as distinct from the rest of the country, sharing more similarities with Belfast and Glasgow than with London. With a significant Irish influx and its status as a port city, Liverpool has maintained international ties, looking towards America and Ireland rather than London."[27][28] The "Make Liverpool/Merseyside an independent state which remains in the EU" petition was submitted on 28 February 2017 during the 2015–2017 Conservative government. The petition aimed to advocate for the independence of Merseyside and its desire to remain in the European Union following the Brexit referendum, however, was rejected by the UK Government and Parliament.

Thirty years ago, amidst economic decline and political discontent, left-wing factions in Liverpool sought to break away from the UK, driven by opposition to Margaret Thatcher's policies. Fuelled by economic struggles—Liverpool lost 80,000 jobs between 1972 and 1982—the city's Labour council, led by the Militant Tendency, embarked on radical socialist initiatives. Despite a brief infusion of funds from the government, the council's request for continued support was denied, intensifying the city's sense of alienation. The episode, marked by political turbulence and anti-Militant sentiment, serves as a historical backdrop to contemporary discussions on regional autonomy within the UK.[29]

In 2020 a new party, the Northern Independence Party (NIP) was formed on making the North of England independent of the South, much like the SNP seeks an independent Scotland.[30] The NIP was formed in order to contest the 2024 general election,[31] its goal being to establish an independent country in the North of England, based on historic Northumbria.[32] While the NIP have nominated York as a proposed capital of an independent Northern England,[33][34] Manchester and Liverpool have also been raised as options.[11]

Regional devolution[edit]

As well as devolution to the North of England as a whole, there have also been proposals for devolution to regions within the North.[35][36]

Yorkshire[edit]

Historic extent (left) and modern definition (right) of Yorkshire

Due both to its size and regional identity, there has existed a Yorkshire Devolution movement, promoting a regionalist form of government for Yorkshire. In 2014, the Yorkshire First Party, later rebranded as the Yorkshire Party, was founded. In recent years, some devolved institutions have been set up in parts of Yorkshire, but none exist across the whole region.

Currently South Yorkshire and West Yorkshire both have devolved Combined Authorities, with the Sheffield City Region and West Yorkshire Combined Authorities set up in 2014, as well as the Tees Valley Combined Authority covering parts of North Yorkshire. There has also been a campaign for a single "One Yorkshire" Combined Authority and elected Mayor, covering the entirety of Yorkshire.[37] This was supported eighteen of the twenty two Yorkshire local authorities, as well as Dan Jarvis, Mayor of the Sheffield City Region;[38] Sheffield and Rotherham councils preferred the South Yorkshire alternative, whilst several North Yorkshire councils were already part of the Tees Valley Combined Authority. A proposal was submitted to the government in March 2018,[39] but was rejected by the government in February 2019.[40] Subsequent to the rejection of the One Yorkshire Combined Authority,[38] despite support continuing for it, new proposals have been made for an East Yorkshire and North Yorkshire Combined Authority.

North East England[edit]

Historic Northumberland and County Durham (left) and modern North East England (right)

North East England was offered a referendum on devolution in 2004, however, voters rejected the proposal by a margin of 77.9% to 22.1%, on a turnout of 48%. More recently, the issue of North East devolution has resurfaced with the establishment of the North East Party in 2014. The party, which is commonly viewed as a sister party of the Yorkshire party, campaigns for a devolved regional government in the North East with powers comparable to those of the nations of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland and has gained four elected councillors on Durham County Council.[41]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Parsons, Rob (2 July 2020). "Future of Humber devolution remains uncertain after row over role of Local Enterprise Partnership chair Stephen Parnaby". The Yorkshire Post. Retrieved 25 February 2021.
  2. ^ a b c Taylor, Peter J. (1 March 1993). "I. The meaning of the north: England's 'foreign country' within?". Political Geography. 12 (2): 137. doi:10.1016/0962-6298(93)90033-4. ISSN 0962-6298.
  3. ^ a b Shaw, Keith (2 January 2018). ""Northern Lights:" An Assessment of the Political and Economic Challenges Facing North East England in the Context of Greater Scottish Autonomy". Journal of Borderlands Studies. 33 (1): 35–52. doi:10.1080/08865655.2016.1270170. ISSN 0886-5655.
  4. ^ Bond, Ross; McCrone, David (1 January 2004). "The growth of English regionalism? institutions and identity". Regional & Federal Studies. 14 (1): 1–25. doi:10.1080/1359756042000245151. ISSN 1359-7566. S2CID 219717167.
  5. ^ a b Coman, Julian (10 October 2013). "Could an independent Scotland be just what northern England needs?". The Guardian.
  6. ^ "Evidence to the Smith Commission on Scottish Devolution". North East Chamber of Commerce. 2014.
  7. ^ "Electoral Commission results page". Retrieved 27 September 2007.
  8. ^ "North East votes 'no' to assembly". BBC News. 5 November 2004.
  9. ^ Stone, Jon (15 May 2015). "New Scotland explained: Could the north of England really break away from Britain?". The Independent.
  10. ^ "North East Poll Backs Move of Powers to Local Areas". BBC News. 5 November 2014.
  11. ^ a b c d Drury, Colin (3 November 2020). "An independent north? What an England severed in two might look like". The Independent.
  12. ^ a b Shaw, Keith; Robinson, Fred; Blackie, Jonathan (13 June 2014). "Borderlands: Rescaling economic development in Northern England in the context of greater Scottish autonomy". Local Economy. 29 (4–5): 412–428. doi:10.1177/0269094214537959. S2CID 154321008.
  13. ^ Rymajdo, Kamila (5 November 2020). "How the North of England Could Gain Independence". Vice.
  14. ^ Robson, Ian (27 May 2014). "North-east devolution? We could be like Plaid Cymru says new party's leader". TeessideLive. Retrieved 5 March 2021.
  15. ^ Rider, Chris (2 April 2015). "The Northern Party: New party targets Lancashire seats". BBC News.
  16. ^ Woods, Lauren (2 April 2015). "Ex Tory MP Forms the Northern Party". The Guardian.
  17. ^ Ball, Jonny (16 October 2020). "How Liverpool's Covid-19 lockdown is stoking dreams of independence". New Statesman. Retrieved 9 December 2020.
  18. ^ Thorp, Liam (23 April 2023). "Who are Liberate Liverpool and what do they stand for". Liverpool Echo. Retrieved 21 December 2023.
  19. ^ Post, The. "'This is heart-breaking. Everyone should read this'". www.livpost.co.uk. Retrieved 21 December 2023.
  20. ^ "Liverpool Community Independents". Retrieved 21 December 2023.
  21. ^ Boland, Philip (2010). "Sonic Geography, Place and Race in the Formation of Local Identity: Liverpool and Scousers". Geografiska Annaler. Series B, Human Geography. 92 (1): 1–22. doi:10.1111/j.1468-0467.2010.00330.x. ISSN 0435-3684. JSTOR 40835383. S2CID 144896001.
  22. ^ academic.oup.com https://academic.oup.com/liverpool-scholarship-online/book/13588/chapter-abstract/167139581?redirectedFrom=fulltext. Retrieved 21 December 2023. {{cite web}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)
  23. ^ Bounds, Andy (19 March 2020). "Liverpool holds fast to its Irish identity through Brexit and beyond". Financial Times. Retrieved 9 December 2020.
  24. ^ Hadfield, Charlotte (14 December 2019). "'Scouse not English' goes viral as Merseyside remains defiant after the election". Liverpool Echo. Retrieved 9 December 2020.
  25. ^ Parker, Emma (13 December 2019). "Liverpool calls for independence from UK as Scousers slam England after Tory win". Daily Star. Retrieved 21 December 2023.
  26. ^ Curran, Aaron (2 July 2022). "'Scouse not English' as hundreds divided over independence". Liverpool Echo. Retrieved 21 December 2023.
  27. ^ Couple. "Liverpool – The Foreign City – Independent Liverpool". Retrieved 21 December 2023.
  28. ^ "history Archives". Liverpool Irish Festival. 8 November 2023. Retrieved 21 December 2023.
  29. ^ "The English city that wanted to 'break away' from the UK". BBC News. 8 November 2014. Retrieved 21 December 2023.
  30. ^ Hackett, John (19 November 2020). "The end of the UK? How broken promises are fuelling a new nationalism in the North". Yorkshire Bylines. Retrieved 20 February 2021.
  31. ^ Duden, Luke (17 December 2020). "Northern Independence Party claims it has support of thousands of voters". SR News. Retrieved 20 February 2021.
  32. ^ Northern Independence Party (12 November 2020). "The case for Northern independence". Red Pepper. Retrieved 20 February 2021.
  33. ^ Lockwood, Tasmin (16 November 2020). "'It doesn't have to be grim up North': New party calls for Northern Independence". The Northern Echo. Retrieved 21 November 2020.
  34. ^ Stone, Ethan (29 October 2020). "Northern Independence Party New Campaign for Independent North-England Explained". Sunderland Echo.
  35. ^ Travers, Tony (3 February 2021). "Devolution in England". UK in a changing Europe. Retrieved 24 February 2021.
  36. ^ Edgar, Laura (5 August 2019). "100% devolution called for in the North". The Planner. Retrieved 24 February 2021.
  37. ^ Web Services. "One Yorkshire devolution". City of York Council. Archived from the original on 14 August 2021. Retrieved 13 August 2020.
  38. ^ a b Meadowcroft, Michael (4 June 2020). "One Yorkshire devolution dream should not be abandoned: Michael Meadowcroft". The Yorkshire Post. Retrieved 13 August 2020.
  39. ^ "Yorkshire Devolution Agreement Submission". york.gov.uk.
  40. ^ "Government rejects Yorkshire devolution". BBC News. 12 February 2019. Retrieved 13 August 2020.
  41. ^ "Durham local election results 2021: How every candidate scored". chroniclelive.co.uk. 24 March 2021. Retrieved 10 April 2021.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Devolution_to_the_North_of_England&oldid=1200508682"