Year | Champions | Score | Runner-up | Venue |
2003 | Montclair State | 86–84 (2OT) | Ramapo | Ramapo Athletic Center (Mahwah, NJ) |
2004 | New Jersey City | 88–75 | Rowan | Athletic & Fitness Center (Jersey City, NJ) |
2005 | Ramapo | 79–71 | Richard Stockton | Bill Bradley Center (Mahwah, NJ) |
2006 | William Paterson | 67–58 | Ramapo | William Paterson Rec Center (Wayne, NJ) |
2007 | Ramapo | 83–81 (OT) | New Jersey City | John J. Moore Athletics Center (Jersey City, NJ) |
2008 | Richard Stockton | 67–66 | William Paterson | Stockton Sports Center (Pomona, NJ) |
2009 | Richard Stockton | 62–54 | Rutgers–Newark | Stockton Sports Center (Pomona, NJ) |
2010 | William Paterson | 70–58 | Richard Stockton | William Paterson Rec Center (Wayne, NJ) |
2011 | New Jersey City | 72–67 | Montclair State | John J. Moore Athletics Center (Jersey City, NJ) |
2012 | William Paterson | 67–63 | Richard Stockton | Stockton Sports Center (Pomona, NJ) |
2013 | Ramapo | 67–65 | Rutgers–Newark | Bill Bradley Center (Mahwah, NJ) |
2014 | Richard Stockton | 65–44 | William Paterson | Stockton Sports Center (Pomona, NJ) |
2015 | Stockton | 65–61 | William Paterson | Stockton Sports Center (Pomona, NJ) |
2016 | Stockton | 60–53 | TCNJ | Stockton Sports Center (Pomona, NJ) |
2017 | Ramapo | 67–64 | New Jersey City | Bill Bradley Center (Mahwah, NJ) |
2018 | Ramapo | 67–59 | William Paterson | Bill Bradley Center (Mahwah, NJ) |
2019 | Rowan | 80–77 | New Jersey City | John J. Moore Athletics Center (Jersey City, NJ) |
2020 | TCNJ | 75–60 | Stockton | Packer Hall (Ewing, NJ) |
2021 | New Jersey City | 79–77 | Stockton | John J. Moore Athletics Center (Jersey City, NJ) |
2022 | Stockton | 95–91 | Rowan | Sports Center (Galloway, NJ) |
2023 | Rowan | 103–88 | Stockton | Esby Gymnasium (Glassboro, NJ) |
2024 | TCNJ | 75–62 | Stockton | Sports Center (Galloway, NJ) |