[ 2] Name on the Register Image Date listed[ 3] Location City or town Description 1 Balcastle Balcastle October 2, 1986 (#86002722 ) NW corner of Herrick and Little Plains Roads 40°53′02″N 72°23′04″W / 40.883889°N 72.384444°W / 40.883889; -72.384444 (Balcastle ) Southampton 2 Beach Road Historic District Beach Road Historic District October 2, 1986 (#86002723 ) Between Shinnecock and Halsely Neck Roads on Beach Road at Barrier Beach 40°51′44″N 72°25′03″W / 40.862222°N 72.4175°W / 40.862222; -72.4175 (Beach Road Historic District ) Southampton 3 Beebe Windmill Beebe Windmill December 27, 1978 (#78001918 ) SE corner of Ocean Road and Hildreth Avenue 40°56′03″N 72°18′05″W / 40.934167°N 72.301389°W / 40.934167; -72.301389 (Beebe Windmill ) Bridgehampton 4 James Benjamin Homestead James Benjamin Homestead August 13, 1986 (#86001510 ) 1182 Flanders Road 40°54′11″N 72°37′04″W / 40.903056°N 72.617778°W / 40.903056; -72.617778 (James Benjamin Homestead ) Flanders 5 The Big Duck The Big Duck April 28, 1997 (#97000164 ) NY 24 , NW of jct. with Bellows Pond Road, Town of Southampton 40°54′25″N 72°37′20″W / 40.906944°N 72.622222°W / 40.906944; -72.622222 (The Big Duck ) Flanders Moved two miles northwest of previous location in 2007 6 Big Duck Ranch Big Duck Ranch September 12, 2008 (#08000866 ) 1012 NY 24 40°54′27″N 72°37′23″W / 40.907614°N 72.622947°W / 40.907614; -72.622947 (Big Duck Ranch ) Flanders Also called the Maurer Duck Farm ; Used for The Big Duck (see above), after nearly several moves along Flanders Road 7 Dr. Wesley Bowers House Upload image October 2, 1986 (#86002699 ) Beach Road (just west of "Road C") 40°51′19″N 72°26′01″W / 40.855278°N 72.433611°W / 40.855278; -72.433611 (Dr. Wesley Bowers House ) Southampton 8 James L. Breese House James L. Breese House April 18, 1980 (#80002778 ) 155 Hill Street 40°53′06″N 72°23′56″W / 40.885°N 72.398889°W / 40.885; -72.398889 (James L. Breese House ) Southampton 9 Bridgehampton Presbyterian Church Bridgehampton Presbyterian Church February 14, 2017 (#100000649 ) 2429 Montauk Hwy. 40°56′10″N 72°18′12″W / 40.936049°N 72.303237°W / 40.936049; -72.303237 (Bridgehampton Presbyterian Church ) Bridgehampton 10 William Cauldwell House Upload image May 4, 2009 (#09000305 ) 51 Peconic Avenue 40°59′24″N 72°22′21″W / 40.989886°N 72.372592°W / 40.989886; -72.372592 (William Cauldwell House ) Noyack 11 William Merritt Chase Homestead William Merritt Chase Homestead June 16, 1983 (#83001808 ) Canoe Place Road and Bathing Beach Road (east of Peconic Road) 40°53′15″N 72°28′38″W / 40.887475°N 72.477184°W / 40.887475; -72.477184 (William Merritt Chase Homestead ) Shinnecock Hills 12 COIMBRA (shipwreck and remains) Upload image September 25, 2013 (#13000779 ) Address Restricted Westhampton From World War II Shipwrecks along the East Coast and Gulf of Mexico MPS 13 William Corwith House William Corwith House July 13, 2013 (#13000463 ) 2368 Montauk Hwy. 40°56′10″N 72°18′21″W / 40.935994°N 72.305757°W / 40.935994; -72.305757 (William Corwith House ) Bridgehampton Currently the headquarters of the Bridgehampton Historical Society 14 Crowther House Crowther House March 21, 1985 (#85000630 ) 97 Beach Lane 40°48′16″N 72°38′03″W / 40.804444°N 72.634167°W / 40.804444; -72.634167 (Crowther House ) Westhampton Beach 15 William A. Farnum Boathouse William A. Farnum Boathouse November 9, 2017 (#100001809 ) 52 Actor's Colony Rd. 41°02′08″N 72°18′26″W / 41.03565°N 72.30721°W / 41.03565; -72.30721 (William A. Farnum Boathouse ) Sag Harbor 1915 boathouse is sole surviving intact structure associated with the life of early 20th century movie star William Farnum 16 First Presbyterian Church First Presbyterian Church April 19, 1994 (#94001194 ) 44 Union Street 40°59′50″N 72°17′39″W / 40.997222°N 72.294167°W / 40.997222; -72.294167 (First Presbyterian Church ) Sag Harbor Egyptian revival church designed by Minard Lafever ; steeple lost in 1938 hurricane 17 Foster-Meeker House Foster-Meeker House August 26, 2009 (#09000656 ) 101 Mill Road 40°48′44″N 72°38′36″W / 40.812342°N 72.643447°W / 40.812342; -72.643447 (Foster-Meeker House ) Westhampton Beach 18 Capt. C. Goodale House Capt. C. Goodale House October 2, 1986 (#86002725 ) 300 Hampton Road 40°53′29″N 72°22′51″W / 40.891389°N 72.380833°W / 40.891389; -72.380833 (Capt. C. Goodale House ) Southampton 19 Jagger House Jagger House December 12, 1978 (#78001920 ) Old Montauk Highway 40°49′00″N 72°40′38″W / 40.816667°N 72.677222°W / 40.816667; -72.677222 (Jagger House ) Westhampton 20 Maycroft Upload image February 24, 1995 (#95000158 ) Ferry Road (NY 114 ) 41°00′33″N 72°18′35″W / 41.009167°N 72.309722°W / 41.009167; -72.309722 (Maycroft ) North Haven 21 North Main Street Historic District North Main Street Historic District October 2, 1986 (#86002730 ) North Main Street near CR 39 and Railroad Station Plaza 40°53′45″N 72°23′27″W / 40.895833°N 72.390833°W / 40.895833; -72.390833 (North Main Street Historic District ) Southampton 22 Quogue Cemetery Upload image December 11, 2013 (#13000914 ) 58 Lamb Ave 40°49′01″N 72°36′18″W / 40.816932°N 72.604906°W / 40.816932; -72.604906 (Quogue Cemetery ) Quogue Graves of early settlers date to mid-18th century, with distinctive period funerary art . 23 Quogue Historic District Quogue Historic District February 2, 2016 (#15001028 ) Quogue Historic District 40°49′07″N 72°36′15″W / 40.818596°N 72.604122°W / 40.818596; -72.604122 (Quogue Historic District ) Quogue District covering most of village shows slow transition from agricultural town to seaside vacation destination. 24 Quogue Life-Saving Station Quogue Life-Saving Station May 27, 1999 (#99000640 ) 78 Dune Road 40°48′26″N 72°36′00″W / 40.807222°N 72.6°W / 40.807222; -72.6 (Quogue Life-Saving Station ) Quogue 25 Rev. Paul Cuffee Gravesite Rev. Paul Cuffee Gravesite October 8, 2010 (#10000852 ) North side of Montauk Highway opposite 216 East Montauk Highway 40°52′56″N 72°30′39″W / 40.88225°N 72.51072°W / 40.88225; -72.51072 (Rev. Paul Cuffee Gravesite ) Hampton Bays Cemeteries of the Town of Southampton, 1640-1930 MPS 26 Rogers Mansion Museum Complex Rogers Mansion Museum Complex January 10, 2012 (#11001010 ) 17 Meetinghouse Ln. Coordinates missing Southampton 1843 Greek Revival mansion built for whaling captain; now used as the Southampton History Museums 27 Nathaniel Rogers House Nathaniel Rogers House March 15, 2005 (#05000170 ) 2539 Montauk Highway 40°56′15″N 72°18′04″W / 40.9375°N 72.301111°W / 40.9375; -72.301111 (Nathaniel Rogers House ) Bridgehampton 28 Rosemary Lodge Rosemary Lodge January 14, 2000 (#99001681 ) 322 Rose Hill Road 40°54′39″N 72°20′19″W / 40.910833°N 72.338611°W / 40.910833; -72.338611 (Rosemary Lodge ) Water Mill 29 Sag Harbor Village District Sag Harbor Village District July 20, 1973 (#73001274 ) Roughly bounded by Sag Harbor, Rysam, Hamilton, Marsden, Main and Long Island Avenues 40°59′50″N 72°17′44″W / 40.997222°N 72.295556°W / 40.997222; -72.295556 (Sag Harbor Village District ) Sag Harbor 30 Sagaponack Historic District Sagaponack Historic District June 2, 2000 (#00000582 ) Roughly along Main Street 40°55′29″N 72°16′40″W / 40.924722°N 72.277778°W / 40.924722; -72.277778 (Sagaponack Historic District ) Sagaponack 31 Shinnecock Hills Golf Club Shinnecock Hills Golf Club September 29, 2000 (#00001211 ) Between County Road and Sebonac Road 40°53′46″N 72°26′28″W / 40.896111°N 72.441111°W / 40.896111; -72.441111 (Shinnecock Hills Golf Club ) Southampton 32 Southampton Village Historic District Southampton Village Historic District April 25, 1988 (#86002726 ) Roughly bounded by Hill and Main Streets, Old Town Road, Atlantic Ocean, Coopers Neck and Halsey Neck Lanes 40°52′37″N 72°23′35″W / 40.876944°N 72.393056°W / 40.876944; -72.393056 (Southampton Village Historic District ) Southampton 33 Ellis Squires Jr. House Ellis Squires Jr. House November 9, 2017 (#100001811 ) 186 and 190 Newtown Rd. 40°53′48″N 72°31′35″W / 40.89676°N 72.52632°W / 40.89676; -72.52632 (Ellis Squires Jr. House ) Hampton Bays 1785 Federal style building is oldest surviving house in Hampton Bays 34 US Post Office-Westhampton Beach US Post Office-Westhampton Beach May 11, 1989 (#88002446 ) 170 Main Street[ 4] 40°48′36″N 72°38′28″W / 40.81°N 72.641111°W / 40.81; -72.641111 (US Post Office-Westhampton Beach ) Westhampton Beach 35 Water Mill Water Mill October 13, 1983 (#83004175 ) Old Mill Road 40°54′33″N 72°21′24″W / 40.909167°N 72.356667°W / 40.909167; -72.356667 (Water Mill ) Water Mill 36 Wickapogue Road Historic District Wickapogue Road Historic District October 2, 1986 (#86002697 ) Wickapogue Road between Narrow Lane and Cobb Road 40°53′01″N 72°22′03″W / 40.883611°N 72.3675°W / 40.883611; -72.3675 (Wickapogue Road Historic District ) Southampton 37 Windmill at Water Mill Windmill at Water Mill December 27, 1978 (#78001919 ) NY 27 and Halsey Lane 40°54′34″N 72°21′15″W / 40.909444°N 72.354167°W / 40.909444; -72.354167 (Windmill at Water Mill ) Water Mill