[3] Name on the Register[4] Image Date listed[5] Location City or town Description 1 The Arcade The Arcade August 5, 1994 (#94000813 ) 31 Circuit Ave.[6] 41°27′21″N 70°33′30″W / 41.455947°N 70.558325°W / 41.455947; -70.558325 (The Arcade ) Oak Bluffs Incorrectly listed on National Register at 134 Circuit Ave. 2 Barn House Barn House December 15, 2011 (#11000920 ) 451 South Rd. 41°20′36″N 70°43′58″W / 41.3432°N 70.732858°W / 41.3432; -70.732858 (Barn House ) Chilmark 3 Cape Poge Light Cape Poge Light September 28, 1987 (#87002040 ) Chappaquiddick Island 41°25′12″N 70°27′10″W / 41.42°N 70.452778°W / 41.42; -70.452778 (Cape Poge Light ) Edgartown 4 East Chop Light East Chop Light June 15, 1987 (#87001480 ) Lighthouse Rd. 41°27′59″N 70°34′16″W / 41.466389°N 70.571111°W / 41.466389; -70.571111 (East Chop Light ) Oak Bluffs 5 Edgartown Harbor Light Edgartown Harbor Light June 15, 1987 (#87001465 ) Off N. Water St. 41°23′33″N 70°30′21″W / 41.3925°N 70.505833°W / 41.3925; -70.505833 (Edgartown Harbor Light ) Edgartown 6 Edgartown Village Historic District Edgartown Village Historic District December 9, 1983 (#83003967 ) Bounded by Water St. (North and South) and Pease's Point Way(North and South) 41°23′25″N 70°30′45″W / 41.390278°N 70.5125°W / 41.390278; -70.5125 (Edgartown Village Historic District ) Edgartown 7 Flying Horses Flying Horses August 27, 1979 (#79000342 ) 33 Oak Bluffs Ave. 41°27′26″N 70°33′28″W / 41.457222°N 70.557778°W / 41.457222; -70.557778 (Flying Horses ) Oak Bluffs National Historic Landmark 8 Gay Head-Aquinnah Town Center Historic District Gay Head-Aquinnah Town Center Historic District February 26, 1999 (#99000187 ) South Rd. and Church St. 41°20′31″N 70°48′50″W / 41.341944°N 70.813889°W / 41.341944; -70.813889 (Gay Head-Aquinnah Town Center Historic District ) Aquinnah Municipal and ecclesiastical buildings in Aquinnah's historic town center. 9 Gay Head-Aquinnah Light Gay Head-Aquinnah Light June 15, 1987 (#87001464 ) Lighthouse Rd. 41°21′02″N 70°50′18″W / 41.350556°N 70.838333°W / 41.350556; -70.838333 (Gay Head-Aquinnah Light ) Aquinnah 1856 lighthouse, near site of oldest (1799) lighthouse on Martha's Vineyard. 10 Polly Hill Arboretum Historic District Polly Hill Arboretum Historic District June 15, 2015 (#15000350 ) 795-833 State Rd. 41°23′51″N 70°40′50″W / 41.3975°N 70.6805°W / 41.3975; -70.6805 (Polly Hill Arboretum Historic District ) West Tisbury 11 Martha's Vineyard Campground Martha's Vineyard Campground December 14, 1978 (#78000439 ) Roughly bounded by Cottage Park, Quequechan, Clinton, Dukes, County, Siloam, Lake, and Central Aves. 41°27′19″N 70°33′41″W / 41.455278°N 70.561389°W / 41.455278; -70.561389 (Martha's Vineyard Campground ) Oak Bluffs Duplicate of Wesleyan Grove 12 Old Mill Old Mill March 29, 1984 (#84002303 ) Edgartown-West Tisbury Rd. 41°22′55″N 70°40′20″W / 41.381944°N 70.672222°W / 41.381944; -70.672222 (Old Mill ) West Tisbury 13 Ritter House Ritter House December 6, 1977 (#77000169 ) Beach St. 41°27′14″N 70°36′10″W / 41.453889°N 70.602778°W / 41.453889; -70.602778 (Ritter House ) Vineyard Haven 14 Tarpaulin Cove Light Tarpaulin Cove Light June 15, 1987 (#87001505 ) Naushon Island 41°28′07″N 70°45′28″W / 41.468611°N 70.757778°W / 41.468611; -70.757778 (Tarpaulin Cove Light ) Gosnold 15 Tashmoo Springs Pumping Station Tashmoo Springs Pumping Station December 3, 2008 (#08001126 ) 325 W. Spring St. 41°26′54″N 70°37′19″W / 41.448388°N 70.622061°W / 41.448388; -70.622061 (Tashmoo Springs Pumping Station ) Tisbury 16 Dr. Harrison A. Tucker Cottage Dr. Harrison A. Tucker Cottage October 22, 1990 (#90000678 ) 61 Ocean Ave.[7] 41°27′20″N 70°33′28″W / 41.455556°N 70.557778°W / 41.455556; -70.557778 (Dr. Harrison A. Tucker Cottage ) Oak Bluffs 17 Union Chapel Union Chapel June 7, 1990 (#90000677 ) Bounded by Circuit, Kennebec, and Narragansett Aves. and Grove St. 41°27′16″N 70°33′31″W / 41.454444°N 70.558611°W / 41.454444; -70.558611 (Union Chapel ) Oak Bluffs 18 U.S. Marine Hospital at Vineyard Haven Upload image February 29, 2024 (#100009983 ) 151 Lagoon Pond Road 41°26′57″N 70°35′59″W / 41.4492°N 70.5996°W / 41.4492; -70.5996 (U.S. Marine Hospital at Vineyard Haven ) Tisbury 19 Edwin DeVries Vanderhoop Homestead Edwin DeVries Vanderhoop Homestead September 6, 2006 (#06000784 ) 35 South Rd. 41°20′43″N 70°50′09″W / 41.345278°N 70.835833°W / 41.345278; -70.835833 (Edwin DeVries Vanderhoop Homestead ) Aquinnah A 19th century Wampanoag homestead, now home to the Aquinnah Cultural Center. 20 Wesleyan Grove Wesleyan Grove April 5, 2005 (#05000458 ) Martha's Vineyard 41°27′23″N 70°33′34″W / 41.456428°N 70.559339°W / 41.456428; -70.559339 (Wesleyan Grove ) Oak Bluffs Duplicate of Martha's Vineyard Campground 21 West Chop Club Historic District West Chop Club Historic District October 18, 2007 (#07001104 ) Iroquois Ave. 41°28′47″N 70°36′15″W / 41.479678°N 70.604147°W / 41.479678; -70.604147 (West Chop Club Historic District ) Tisbury 22 West Chop Light Station West Chop Light Station June 15, 1987 (#87001506 ) W. Chop Rd. 41°28′55″N 70°36′14″W / 41.481944°N 70.603889°W / 41.481944; -70.603889 (West Chop Light Station ) Tisbury 23 William Street Historic District William Street Historic District January 27, 1983 (#83000571 ) Williams St. from Wood Lawn Ave. to 24 Williams St. 41°27′25″N 70°36′24″W / 41.456944°N 70.606667°W / 41.456944; -70.606667 (William Street Historic District ) Tisbury