Year | Champion | Score | Runner-up | Site | Most valuable player | Ref. |
1989 | Vermont | 1–0 | Hartford | Virtue Field • Burlington, Vermont | Kevin Wylie, Vermont | |
1990 | Vermont (2) | 1–1† (6–5 pen.) | Boston U | Nickerson Field • Boston, Massachusetts | Roberto Beall, Vermont | |
1991 | Hartford | 2–0 | Boston U | Elvis Thomas, Hartford | |
1992 | Hartford (2) | 2–0 | Vermont | George Kostelis, Hartford | |
1993 | Boston U | 1–0 | New Hampshire | Ohiri Field • Cambridge, Massachusetts | Tom Giatrakos, Boston U | |
1994 | Boston U (2) | 3–1 | New Hampshire | Nickerson Field • Boston, Massachusetts | Gisle Sorli, Boston U | |
1995 | Boston U (3) | 3–1 | Towson | Vidas Field • Philadelphia, Pennsylvania | Ola Olsen, Boston U | |
1996 | Boston U (4) | 2–1 | Northeastern | Hormel Stadium • Medford, Massachusetts | Nick Bone, Boston U | |
1997 | Boston U (5) | 2–1 | Hofstra | Shuart Stadium • Hempstead, New York | |
1998 | Drexel | 2–1 | Towson | Tiger Soccer Complex • Towson, Maryland | Pete Shay, Drexel | |
1999 | Hartford (3) | 2–0 | Towson | Al-Marzook Field at Alumni Stadium • West Hartford, Connecticut | Cristoffer Hartmann, Hartford | |
2000 | Vermont (3) | 2–1 | Hofstra | Virtue Field • Burlington, Vermont | Mike Dias, Vermont | |
2001 | Towson | 1–0 | Northeastern | Tiger Soccer Complex • Towson, Maryland | Chris Hurley, Towson | |
2002 | Northeastern | 2–1 | Vermont | Parsons Field • Brookline, Massachusetts | Atha Kirkopolous, Northeastern | |
2003 | Binghamton | 1–1† (3–2 pen.) | Northeastern | Bearcats Sports Complex • Binghamton, New York | Stefan Gonet, Binghamton | |
2004 | Boston U (6) | 2–2† (5–3 pen.) | Binghamton | Nickerson Field • Boston, Massachusetts | Federico Bianchi, Boston U | |
2005 | Stony Brook | 1–1† (4–2 pen.) | Binghamton | Kenneth P. LaValle Stadium • Stony Brook, New York | Douglas Narvaez, Stony Brook | |
2006 | Binghamton (2) | 1–0* | Vermont | Bearcats Sports Complex • Binghamton, New York | Barry Neville, Binghamton | |
2007 | Vermont (4) | 1–0 | Binghamton | Roger Scully, Vermont | |
2008 | Boston U (8) | 1–0 | Binghamton | Nickerson Field • Boston, Massachusetts | Jin Oh, Boston U | |
2009 | Stony Brook (2) | 2–0 | UMBC | Kenneth P. LaValle Stadium • Stony Brook, New York | Anthony Rogic, Stony Brook | |
2010 | UMBC | 0–0† (5–4 pen.) | New Hampshire | Retriever Soccer Park • Baltimore, Maryland | Levi Houapeu, UMBC | |
2011 | Stony Brook (3) | 4–2 | Hartford | Kenneth P. LaValle Stadium • Stony Brook, New York | Leonardo Fernandes, Stony Brook | |
2012 | UMBC (2) | 0–0† (4–2 pen.) | New Hampshire | Retriever Soccer Park • Baltimore, Maryland | Phil Saunders, UMBC | [2] |
2013 | UMBC (3) | 4–0 | Hartford | Pete Caringi III, UMBC | [3] |
2014 | UMBC^ (4) | 2–1 | Hartford | Greg Hauck, UMBC | [4] |
2015 | Vermont (5) | 1–0 | Binghamton | Virtue Field • Burlington, Vermont | Brian Wright, Vermont | [5] |
2016 | Albany (1) | 1–0 | Hartford | Bob Ford Field • Albany, New York | Bernardo Mattos, Albany | [n 2] |
2017 | Albany (2) | 1–0* | UMass Lowell | Cushing Field Complex • Lowell, Massachusetts | Daniel Krutzen, Albany | [8] |
2018 | New Hampshire | 5–0 | UMBC | Wildcat Stadium • Durham, New Hampshire | Josh Bauer, New Hampshire | [9] |
2019 | New Hampshire (2) | 1–0 | Hartford | [10] |
2020 | New Hampshire (3) | 2–0 | Vermont | Victor Menudier, New Hampshire | [11] |
2021 | Vermont (6) | 1–0 | New Hampshire | Adrian Schulze Solano, Vermont | [12] |
2022 | New Hampshire (4) | 2–0 | Albany | Jassem Koleilat, New Hampshire | [13] |
2023 | Bryant | 1–0* | New Hampshire | Antreas Hadjigavriel, Bryant | [14] |